2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe | Alexandra's Kitchen (2024)

Home » Recipe Type » Drinks » 2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe

5 from 4 reviews

//By Alexandra Stafford onDecember 19, 2014 (updated November 7, 2020) Jump To Recipe

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.

2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe | Alexandra's Kitchen (1)

This homemade limoncello recipe hails from an Italian friend’s mother, Antonietta. It’s a two-phase process, so you’ll need to plan 3 to 4 days in advance, but the work is mostly hands-off, and the recipe is incredibly simple. Homemade limoncello makes a great gift — it’s such a festive drink to have on hand during the holiday season. Top it with heavy cream and serve it after dinner. Cheers!

How to Make Homemade Limoncello

Phase one:

  1. Peel two pounds organic lemons. This is my favorite peeler for this task.
  2. Place in a Mason jar.
  3. Pour vodka or grain alcohol overtop.
  4. Let sit three to four days, shaking every so often.

Phase two:

  1. Strain out the zest.
  2. Make a simple syrup, and pour it over the zest-infused alcohol.
  3. Bottle it all up, store in the freezer.

How easy is that?

Here’s the play-by-play: First, place the lemon peel in a Mason jar and cover with vodka or grain alcohol.

2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe | Alexandra's Kitchen (2)

After three or four days, the zest will petrify in the alcohol. At this point, strain it out and discard.

2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe | Alexandra's Kitchen (3)

Make a simple syrup and add to the zest-infused alcohol. When you use grain alcohol, the mixture will glow.

2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe | Alexandra's Kitchen (4)

Funnel the limoncello into glass bottles.

2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe | Alexandra's Kitchen (5)
2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe | Alexandra's Kitchen (6)

If you live in the area, Honest Weight Food Co-op in Albany sells these glass jars in a variety of sizes for a little over a dollar a piece:

2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe | Alexandra's Kitchen (7)

This is Antonietta, the lovely Italian mother of friends of ours, who taught us how to make this limoncello. (Incidentally, she also taught us how to make prosciutto.)

2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe | Alexandra's Kitchen (8)

This is the cold room of Antonietta’s basem*nt. Prosciutto and capicola hang from the ceiling.

2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe | Alexandra's Kitchen (9)
2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe | Alexandra's Kitchen (10)

Homemade wine aging in carboys line the perimeter:

2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe | Alexandra's Kitchen (11)

Print

2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe | Alexandra's Kitchen (12)

2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

5 from 4 reviews

  • Author: Alexandra Stafford
  • Total Time: 72 hours 20 minutes
  • Yield: 4 servings
Print Recipe

Save Recipe

Description

Note: Vodka or grain alcohol? I have used both. Vodka is less potent, less body warming, and more subtle in flavor than grain alcohol. Both work well, but my preference is vodka. Unfortunately, vodka doesn’t cause the finished limoncello to glow the way grain alcohol does.

Ingredients

  • 2-lbs organic lemons
  • 1 750-ml bottle vodka or grain alcohol
  • 6 cups water
  • 2 ½ cups sugar

Instructions

  1. Peel lemons with peeler, trying to avoid white pith if possible.
  2. Place the zest in one or two large glass mason jars and pour vodka over top.
  3. Let the zest sit in the vodka for 3 or 4 days shaking every so often. Strain the vodka, which will feel petrified, into a large bowl and discard the zest.
  4. Next, heat the water and sugar until the sugar is completely dissolved. Let cool completely. Add sugar-water mixture to strained vodka. Pour into bottles and store in freezer.
  5. Serve as is or topped with heavy cream.
  • Prep Time: 10 minutes
  • Cook Time: 10 minutes
  • Category: Drink
  • Method: Steep and Stir
  • Cuisine: Italian

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.

Gifts Christmas Drinks

« Previous PostHolly’s Challah Bread Recipe

2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe | Alexandra's Kitchen (13)

Buy My Cookbook!

Recipes for no-knead loaves and meals to savor every slice.

Buy now »

Want to Chop Like a Pro?

Get your free 8-video tutorial

    46 Comments on “2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe”

  1. Alicia (foodycat)Reply

    I want to visit Antonietta’s house!

    • alexandraReply

      Come visit! Any plans to visit the States? You have a home in upstate NY! And I am sure Antonietta would love to give you a tour 🙂

  2. sue|theviewfromgreatislandReply

    I can’t resist that fabulous glow! Sharing this today…

    • alexandraReply

      Thank you Sue!

  3. SandraReply

    Yum!

    • alexandraReply

      Sandra, I have a bottle for you. Stop by immediately, or I’ll chuck it out the window into your ice rink.

  4. CarrieReply

    What a magical life you lead! I love catching up with you and the family via your beautiful blog. Hope you guys are well (it seems so)! Enjoy the holidays with your three wee ones! XO!

    • alexandraReply

      Oh Carrie, so great to hear from you! My only regret about leaving VA is not taking a tour of your basem*nt and Mike’s home-brewing operation. Every Xmas I think about investing in the mini fridge and keg and brewing kit, and then I get scared. I think next winter we will be ready. Happy Holidays to you and your family!! xo

  5. aliReply

    That basem*nt would make any house my dream home. It’s kind of making me wish I lived somewhere colder, where basem*nts are standard– and as a born and raised SoCal girl, that’s never been on my list before.

    Can you please clarify what it means for the zest or the vodka to “petrify”? I’ve never heard that before, thanks!

    • alexandraReply

      Me, too 🙂 Where in SoCal are you? I lived in San Clemente for three years. It was a dream.

      So, the zest doesn’t totally petrify as in the true meaning of the word, but after 3 or 4 days in the vodka, it becomes rock hard, so when you strain it and feel it, it will crack and crumble like potato chips.

  6. Alley @ alleys recipe bookReply

    I made limoncello once before… The recipe I was following required three months! And it didn’t turn that creamy yellow color that you see in Italy either. Maybe I shall try again!

    • alexandraReply

      Yes, definitely do! This recipe couldn’t be simpler!

  7. LizReply

    Antonietta looks even more lovely than her limocello. What a perfect
    post for last minute ideas and maybe a potion to keep us all calm during the holiday madness!

  8. Mary DianeReply

    The photo of the limoncello with the black background should be framed. Magnificent photography!!!!

    • alexandraReply

      Thank you Mary Diane!

  9. dawnReply

    I shared this post on my pinterest and facebook pages. this post is jam packed with great ideas… I am quickly becoming a fan of this site… Thank you!!!!

    • alexandraReply

      Oh thank you! You are too kind!

  10. Carol at Wild Goose TeaReply

    I loved this post—-meeting Antoinette and all the wonderful
    goodies. ‘Meeting’ a bit of your grandmother. Sweet—Happy Holidays!!!!!

  11. JeromeReply

    Hi Alexandra-

    Funny I saw in earlier comments that you used to live in San Clemente which is where we reside!

    I served this last night to neighbors at a casual holiday cookie exchange ( I used fresh lemons from our backyard tree). It was well received, and the cream was a nice touch.

    Question for you- I brewed the lemon rinds for three days but my completed batch never glowed like your final picture. Any suggestions for next time?

    • alexandraReply

      So fun, Jerome! I miss San Clemente so much. Where do you live? We lived on Acebo Lane, a tiny street just a few blocks from the pier. It was a dream!

      Amazing that you made limoncello from your own lemons! OK, I think I have an idea as to why your final batch didn’t “glow.” Did you use vodka? And if so, what proof? The batch I made with vodka also did not glow, unfortunately — I need to make a note of this in the recipe — and I asked Jim (Antonietta’s son) why and he referred to something called the “ouzo effect,” and basically said that if the alcohol isn’t a high enough proof, it won’t glow or become cloudy. So, I need to find a high-proof vodka bc I do prefer the taste, but I also love the glowing yellow color.

      Anyway, so sorry for the delay here! I will report back if I make any discoveries re glowing vodka 🙂

  12. EarleneReply

    Made this for the holiday. we are not sure on it! Just kidding!!! I could get in trouble with this deliciousness!!! Sadly, I don’t drink much and too old! LOL!!!

    • alexandraReply

      Haha, love it 🙂

  13. EarleneReply

    Just wanted you to know that one bottle broke in the freezer, but didn’t totally make a mess till I moved said bottle, I am sad!! Oh well, I didn’t know if that bottle would stand the freezer anyhow, but still have 2 bottles left, well, maybe 1 1/2 bottles left, :)!!!

  14. LADY TOFUReply

    Can another type of sweetener (agave, maple syrup?) be used as a substitute ( with equal effectiveness)?

    Thanks!!!!!!

  15. SarahReply

    Great instructional! Your pictures are absolutely stunning.
    I just wanted to emphasize something you pointed out. Lemons used for limoncello must be organic. It is virtually impossible to remove the chemical accrued from conventional growing from the lemon peel. The couple extra dollars is certainly worth it!

    • alexandraReply

      Yes, absolutely, thank you for emphasizing! Organic is important here.

  16. CarolReply

    How long does this last please ?

  17. TaylorReply

    Does it have to remain refrigerated? I think this would be cute to send to some of my friends.

    • alexandraReply

      I think mostly for serving purposes. I don’t know much about limoncello but I think typically it is stored in the freezer and served ice cold. It makes a great gift for sure!

  18. Stella jonesReply

    What a muddled page, too full of ads. Terrible

    • alexandraReply

      Do you know what it costs to run a blog? Those ads muddling up the page allow you to access recipes for FREE.

      Happy Holidays to you!

  19. SallyReply

    I’m trying this for the first time and did not realize the importance of organic lemons until too late. Is my recipe doomed?

  20. AnnEReply

    My batch was very sweet….too sweet to enjoy. I think that it might be because I used Meyer lemons which are not as acidic as “regular” lemons. Also, it was not lemon in color but instead more yellow/red which I’m sure is also due to the fact that I used Meyer lemons. Thoughts?

    • alexandraReply

      Bummer … yeah, I haven’t made this with Meyers, but that would make sense regarding the sweetness and color. I’ve always just used organic lemons. You may want to compare the ratios, too, to other recipes because that might encourage you to reduce the sugar. Sorry about this!

      • AnnEReply

        Not your fault at all!

  21. SandraReply

    DON’T THROW OUT THOSE LEMON PEELS!!!! Instead you can candy them or preserve them The Alcohol adds another dimension to them and can be used in candy making or in savory recipes as well

    • CaralineReply

      Thank you!!!

  22. WilliamReply

    Hi Alexandra, when pouring the vodka over zest in mason jars, do you leave the jars open or put a lid on them?

    • alexandraReply

      Hi William! I cover the jars.

  23. Robert HendersonReply

    Iwasgiven a small bottle made from this recipe by my granddaughter and after consumming it Iencouraged her to get cracking on the next batch.

    • alexandraReply

      I hope she listened!! So nice to hear this, Robert 🍋🍋🍋🍋

  24. Carmen DapilosReply

    I love the Italian Limoncillo very much. How I wish to follow the recipe, but here in the Philippines our local “Lemosito” is green and smaller compared to the European lemons. So, Limoncillo drink needs only the peel and not the juice? Would it be possible to use our local Lemonsitos?

    • alexandraReply

      Hi Carmen! Yes, only the peel! I think you should definitely give your lemonsitos a try!

  25. SandiReply

    Just found your Limoncello recipe so am going to give it a try. I just have to convert yur measurements as I live in Australia and we are on a metric system. Fortunately I have my own organic lemon tree.

    • alexandraReply

      How nice to have a lemon tree! Sorry the measurements are not in metric … hope the conversion goes OK.

  26. TomReply

    Excited to try this. Thanks

2-Phase Homemade Limoncello Recipe | Alexandra's Kitchen (2024)

FAQs

Why don't you use lemon juice in limoncello? ›

Variation: Adding Lemon Juice

This will make the finished beverage more cloudy, while at the same time adding a sour note to the sweet, boozy lemon liqueur. The more juice you add, the more sour the finished liquid will become. We couldn't decide which method we liked better—so we did both!

Can bacteria grow in limoncello? ›

The high alcohol content of limoncello generally inhibits the growth of bacteria, making them unlikely to flourish. However, improper storage or contamination during the manufacturing process can potentially lead to the growth of bacteria. It is therefore important to follow proper hygiene and storage practices.

What is the best vodka to use when making limoncello? ›

If you have the option, 100 proof vodka or even higher-proof grain alcohol is the very best to use for making limoncello. This will extract more and better lemon flavor from the peels, and makes a smoother, less cloying limoncello.

Should limoncello be clear or cloudy? ›

Each of these starting solutions is completely transparent; limoncello itself, however, is 'turbid', with a cloudy, opaque appearance. Turbid systems pervade everyday life: other examples include ice crystals in clouds, fat droplets in milk, and algae in a pond.

Why is my homemade limoncello bitter? ›

The most important thing is to have as little pith [ the white stuff under the lemon peel ] as possible. Too much will make your limoncello bitter – drinkable but bitter. You can use a zester, vegetable peeler or an intensely sharp knife.

What can I do with the lemon peels after making limoncello? ›

If you have extra rinds on your hands from preserving lemons and you've already made vats of limoncello, you can cut those rinds into smaller pieces and stuff them into your jars of preserved lemons for bonus pieces. But enough about the preserved lemons. Today, limoncello enjoys its day in the spotlight.

Can you infuse limoncello too long? ›

A: It can rest a really long time. There's nothing in it that would really go bad and I've tasted batches that rested for over 5 years with no problems.

Is limoncello good for your gut? ›

Limoncello on its own is categorized as a digestif liqueur, meaning it's meant to be sipped on its own after a meal to aid in digestion. This is how limoncello is commonly used in Italy—after a meal, people stay at the table, either after dessert or during dessert, sharing limoncello and toasting to good health.

How can you tell if limoncello has gone bad? ›

Can Limoncello Go Bad or Expire? You should generally try to consume limoncello within 2 years of creating or opening it. Limoncello only contains 4 ingredients, 2 of which are preservatives. So, it will never “go bad” like milk would but it does lose its lemon scent and flavor over time.

Is it cheaper to make your own limoncello? ›

A bottle at the liquor store will run $20 to $35. Making your own costs even more: Traditional homemade limoncello recipes, like our favorite from The New York Times (arkansasonline.com/215limoncello/) take weeks to make and can cost you $45 or more depending on your preferred vodka.

What is the best jar for limoncello? ›

1) A one gallon glass jar with a screw-on lid: You can get on at Amazon through that link or Home Goods is a good place to get these locally for a reasonable price. You can get smaller ones for smaller batches but I wouldn't recommend it unless space is really THAT tight for you.

What's the difference between Limoncino and limoncello? ›

Well, yes and no — while both drinks are made from essentially the same ingredients, they have different names. And like most things Italian, it's a regional thing. In the North, around the Portofino/Cinque Terre region (close to Lucca), it's Limoncino. In the South, around Naples/Sorrento, it's Limoncello.

Do you have to sterilize bottles for limoncello? ›

on the fourth day, sterilize the wine bottles for the limuncinu: place them in a sink and fill them with boiling water. after a few minutes, drain the bottles and let them cool. (because the alcohol content is a great deal higher than wine, the rigorous sterilization process required for that purpose is not necessary.)

How do you sterilize glass bottles for limoncello? ›

Place bottles and metal lids on an oven tray. Place in the oven for 20 minutes. Remove while still hot. Alternatively, place bottles and plastic lids in the dishwasher on the hottest cycle.

Why is my limoncello frozen? ›

Limoncello is stored in the freezer so it can be served chilled- if you use 80 proof, your drink will turn to ice.

Does limoncello contain lemon juice? ›

Limoncello is made of lemon peels, lemon juice, vodka, sugar, and water. The lemons infuse the vodka for a few weeks, giving it an intense lemon flavor. Then, the sugar syrup is added to sweeten the drink and it's chilled for a few days.

Can I substitute lemon juice for limoncello? ›

If you wish to avoid alcohol then a mixture of 150ml/⅔ cup of elderflower cordial (elderflower syrup) and 100ml/7 tablespoons of fresh lemon juice would be the best alternative.

Why did my limoncello curdle? ›

Exposure to air and heat over time will eventually cause it to go bad, and curdling is a sure sign that it's no longer suitable for drinking. Q: How do I drink or serve crema di limoncello properly?

How do you fix bitter limoncello? ›

Re: Redistilling bitter limoncello

Try adding a teeny pinch of salt. It kills bitterness. Just a little bit though.. like 0.005% or something.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Terrell Hackett

Last Updated:

Views: 6579

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (52 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Terrell Hackett

Birthday: 1992-03-17

Address: Suite 453 459 Gibson Squares, East Adriane, AK 71925-5692

Phone: +21811810803470

Job: Chief Representative

Hobby: Board games, Rock climbing, Ghost hunting, Origami, Kabaddi, Mushroom hunting, Gaming

Introduction: My name is Terrell Hackett, I am a gleaming, brainy, courageous, helpful, healthy, cooperative, graceful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.