The Creamy Ingredient That Makes Box Cake Mix Richer - Tasting Table (2024)

ByHope Ngo/

Many of us have a complicated relationship with boxed cake mix, particularly those who pride themselves on being "from scratch" bakers. But as noted cookbook author Anne Byrn, also known as The Cake Mix Doctor, points out, it doesn't have to be that way since cake mixes have the same ingredients we use to make baked desserts ourselves. This goes from flour to sugar and raising agents to flavorings.

In her book "The Cake Mix Doctor," Byrne adds that boxed mixes have something scratch cakes don't: They have decades of corporate research and development behind them, making them no-fail cakes. She further quotes her friend's mother in another book, "A New Take on Cake," who said: "Why on earth would I want to bake a scratch cake when Mr. Hines and Mrs. Crocker have been doing it so well for years?"

Sour cream can provide a tangy taste and extra moisture

But no matter how consistently well-boxed mixes turn out, there are still ways we can elevate the cakes that we make with them. Some bakers might add an extra egg. Others might want to swap vegetable oil for melted butter. Some will add ingredients that might give the cake a homemade taste, like chocolate chips, nuts, or shredded coconut. Bakers may also upgrade the liquid added to the mix — going from water to sour cream to create memorable, moist, tender cakes.

Sour cream is — as its name suggests, acream that has been soured by adding lactic acid bacteria, which is a known probiotic, and then leaving the mix to settle. Most of us know sour cream as a key ingredient for party dips and salad dressings and a trusted sidekick for savory dishes,including baked potatoes and nachos. Sour cream even plays a leading role in the cream sauce for beef stroganoff.

But thanks to its high milk fat content at 18% and the lactic acid used to make it tangy, sour cream elevates cake byadding both texture and flavor. As Tracy Wilk of the Institute of Culinary Education tells Martha Stewart, not only does its sour taste add a tang, but the fat in the rich cream "shortens gluten strands, leading to the most tender baked goods."

The best way to use sour cream with a boxed mix is to add up to a cupor essentially the same amount of liquid you were originally meant to add, per the manufacturer's instructions. Just don't forget why you're adding sour cream and forgo the whole-fat version for reduced-fat or non-fat versions, and your tastebuds will thank you.

How to use sour cream with boxed cake mix

The Creamy Ingredient That Makes Box Cake Mix Richer - Tasting Table (3)

Yelenayemchuk/Getty Images

The best way to use sour cream with a boxed cake mix is to use it to replace the other liquids in the recipe, like milk or water. You canadd up to a cup,or essentially the same amount of liquid you were originally meant to add, per the manufacturer's instructions. Just don't forget why you're adding sour cream and forgo the whole-fat version for reduced-fat or non-fat versions, and your tastebuds will thank you. Remember, it's the fat from the sour cream that does the magic here.

If you don't have sour cream on-hand, you can also try full-fat yogurt. The results will still be delicious — and way better than if you'd just followed the directions on the box — but they won't be exactly the same.

Recommended

The Creamy Ingredient That Makes Box Cake Mix Richer - Tasting Table (2024)

FAQs

The Creamy Ingredient That Makes Box Cake Mix Richer - Tasting Table? ›

Thanks to its high milk fat content at 18%, sour cream elevates the most basic cake mixes by adding both texture and flavor.

How do you make a cake taste richer? ›

  1. Add an Extra Egg.
  2. Add Milk, Coffee, or Soda.
  3. Use Butter Instead of Oil.
  4. Add Instant Pudding.
  5. Up the Flavor with an Extract or Citrus Zest.
  6. Top the Cake with Homemade Frosting.
Oct 19, 2023

What adds richness to cakes? ›

The milk adds fat, which results in a better flavor and density in your cake. If you want to make your cake extra rich, swap out the milk for buttermilk. Because buttermilk is extra thick, use a few more tablespoons than the recipe calls for.

What makes a box cake mix better? ›

Using your Mad Hungry Spurtle Set, sift and stir your eggs, fats, and liquids, to achieve that velvety batter we all know and love.
  1. Replace Water with Milk or Buttermilk.
  2. Substitute Oil for Butter.
  3. Use More Eggs.
  4. Add Vanilla Extract.
  5. Make It a Chocolate Lovers' Cake. ...
  6. Decorate Your Cake Like A Pro.

How do you enrich a box cake mix? ›

Enrich with fat.

Mix in room-temperature cream cheese, ricotta, sour cream, whole-fat yogurt, or peanut butter in addition to the fat called for on the box to yield even richer cakes.

How to make box cake more dense and moist? ›

How To Make Boxed Cake Denser
  1. Add 2 extra egg yolks. ...
  2. Swap out oil for melted butter. ...
  3. Add 2 mashed ripe bananas, fold in just before baking. ...
  4. Add 1 cup pumpkin purée, fold in just before baking. ...
  5. Swap out water for coconut milk. ...
  6. Swap out oil for ricotta cheese. ...
  7. Add 4 ounces of chocolate, melted. ...
  8. Swap out water for heavy cream.
May 16, 2023

How do you make a cake taste like a bakery cake? ›

8 Ways To Make Boxed Cake Mix Taste Homemade
  1. Swap Oil for Melted Butter.
  2. Exchange Water for Dairy.
  3. Enhance With Extracts.
  4. Incorporate Sour Cream or Mayo.
  5. Add Nuts.
  6. Make Homemade Frosting.
  7. Layer With Fillings.
  8. Turn it into a Poke Cake.
Apr 12, 2024

What makes cake more moist, butter or oil? ›

Vegetable oil contributes moistness far more reliably, a result of the fact that oil remains liquid at room temperature while butter solidifies. Liquid contributes to the sensation of moistness, and therefore cakes made with oil often present as moister than their butter-based counterparts.

What is a secret ingredient for cakes? ›

Mayonnaise: The Hidden Gem in Cake Recipes

This unexpected addition can take your cake recipes to a whole new level. To incorporate mayonnaise into your cake batter, simply add a couple of tablespoons to the mix. The result? A tender and moist cake that will have everyone asking for seconds.

Is box cake better with oil or butter? ›

Which is why I always substitute an equal amount of melted butter for vegetable oil, which is typically called for on the cake mix box. Melted butter serves the same purpose as oil, while also adding richness and depth to the cake.

Does box cake taste better with milk or water? ›

Use milk instead of water

Most box cake recipes will tell you to add water to the mix. Instead, try adding milk using the same proportions. This will make the cake richer and creamier because it ups the fat content. You can even use buttermilk here for a pleasant tang.

What does adding pudding to cake mix do? ›

Put some pudding in the mix: Add a small box of pudding mix in with the cake mix. (Don't make the pudding.) The mix adds additional flavor, moistness, and a denser texture.

Why is Betty Crocker cake mix so good? ›

What's inside: While every other mix uses sugar for sweetening, Betty Crocker's mix uses both sugar and corn syrup. Corn syrup is used in baking as an invert sugar—that is, a sugar that stays in liquid form at room temperature. It's an ingredient that's used to add sweetness, but also to retain moisture.

What can I add to cake mix to make it taste better? ›

Try adding a few of these tips to your box cake mix taste better!
  1. Use milk instead of water. ...
  2. Add extra eggs. ...
  3. Add sugar and flour to the dry mix. ...
  4. Use coffee instead of water for chocolate cakes. ...
  5. Sour Cream is perfect for adding moisture and rich flavor. ...
  6. Pudding adds moisture and flavor.

How to make a fluffier box cake? ›

Swap out each cup of water called for with milk. Buttermilk: Instead of water, use the same amount of buttermilk. The acid in the buttermilk interacts with the leavening agents in the mix for a better rise. "Swapping out the water for buttermilk creates a fluffier cake and a moister one, too," says Waterson.

Can I replace oil with melted butter in cake mix? ›

Most cake mixes call for oil, but butter will bring in amazing flavor. To substitute butter for oil in baking just melt the butter, measure it, let it cool, and add it as you would the oil. Compared to oil, butter will create a cake with a firmer, cakeier texture.

How do you fix a bad tasting cake? ›

One way to fix a bitter cake is to add a small amount of an acidic component, which is highly recommended especially when you toss in too much baking soda. If your cake recipe contains chocolate, you can add a ½ teaspoon of cocoa powder. Here are some other ingredients you can try: Lemon juice.

Why do my cakes never taste good? ›

Most common reason is when the oven door is opened too soon and the cake hasn't set up and baked properly. The mixture could be too soft due to not enough ingredients or if there is too much liquid added. Using too much raising agents can make the cake rise too much too quickly and it implodes on itself.

How do you increase the moistness of a cake? ›

Try switching out any water in your recipe for full-fat milk or buttermilk for a moist, decadent texture. Another ingredient that can enhance the moisture of your cake is mayonnaise. Adding a dollop of mayonnaise to your batter can help make your freshly baked cake softer with an added boost of moisture.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Merrill Bechtelar CPA

Last Updated:

Views: 6260

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Merrill Bechtelar CPA

Birthday: 1996-05-19

Address: Apt. 114 873 White Lodge, Libbyfurt, CA 93006

Phone: +5983010455207

Job: Legacy Representative

Hobby: Blacksmithing, Urban exploration, Sudoku, Slacklining, Creative writing, Community, Letterboxing

Introduction: My name is Merrill Bechtelar CPA, I am a clean, agreeable, glorious, magnificent, witty, enchanting, comfortable person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.