Bake Off's Mel and Sue quit on day one after tears left a bad taste (2024)

Mel Giedroyc and Sue Perkins’ seven-series tenure as hosts of The Great British Bake Off nearly did not happen after they resigned on the first day of filming.

The pair have revealed that they quit because they feared producers wanted to make a more intrusive and crueller show than they were happy with.

“We resigned, basically,” Perkins told the Radio Times. “Because it was not a kind show. They were pointing cameras in the bakers’ faces and making them cry and saying, ‘Tell us about your dead gran.’ So we had very stiff words about how we wanted to proceed. I think we can say that, now we’re out of it, can’t we?”

Mel and Sue’s chemistry and gentle, innuendo-packed presenting style was a big part of the programme’s success as it grew from an audience of 2 million on BBC Two to nearly 16 million at its peak on BBC One.

When Channel 4 came knocking with a £25m-a-year deal to broadcast a show, which had become a BBC staple, the pair – along with Mary Berry – declined to move.

They declared: “We’ve had the most amazing time on Bake Off, and have loved seeing it rise and rise like a pair of yeasted Latvian baps. We’re not going with the dough.”

Giedroyc and Perkins have worked together on stage and television since they met 32 years ago at Cambridge University.

They said they only continued with Bake Off after a frank discussion with producers about the nature of the programme.

“We’re quite cheesy and homespun and we just want to have a laugh,” said Perkins. “Who wants to see people crying? I don’t. Especially if you work in television and you know the mechanisms that have been used to make them cry.”

They say they properly quit Bake Off in 2016 after hearing on a television news bulletin that the programme, made by Love Productions, was being poached by Channel 4.

It was painful, said Perkins. “There’s no antagonism there. I just think, ‘If you’re going to let us find out that way [from TV], then we’re not really a team, are we?’”

Paul Hollywood did go to Channel 4, starting a successful judging partnership with Prue Leith. The pairing of Sandi Toksvig and Noel Fielding as new hosts was a surprise but most Bake Off fans seem to agree it has worked, with the tone set by Giedroyc and Perkins continuing.

Toksvig announced she was stepping down in January after three years presenting the show.

Last week Matt Lucas was named as her replacement, saying: “I’m chuffed to bits to be joining the most delicious show on television. I can’t wait to break bread with Noel, Prue and Paul and meet the brilliant bakers. And bearing in mind my love of cake, I’ve already ordered some much larger trousers in anticipation. See you in the tent!”

Giedroyc and Perkins will soon be seen together playing assassins in a new Sky One comedy, Hitmen.

Bake Off's Mel and Sue quit on day one after tears left a bad taste (2024)

FAQs

Bake Off's Mel and Sue quit on day one after tears left a bad taste? ›

"On day one we had quite a frank chat with the producers," Giedroyc said. "We resigned, basically," Perkins said. "Because it was not a kind show. They were pointing cameras in the bakers' faces and making them cry and saying, 'Tell us about your dead gran.

What was the biggest Bake Off scandal? ›

#Bingate. Arguably one of the most controversial moments in the Bake Off tent ever; when Iain Watters ice cream melted after his fellow contestant Diana Beard removed his dessert from the freezer during the 2014 series.

Why did Sue and Mel leave Bake Off? ›

The pair have revealed that they quit because they feared producers wanted to make a more intrusive and crueller show than they were happy with. “We resigned, basically,” Perkins told the Radio Times. “Because it was not a kind show.

Why did Mary leave Bake Off? ›

Mary left GBBO because the U.K. series switched networks. The show, which originally aired on BBC, decided to move to Channel 4 instead of sticking with BBC. Unhappy with the decision, Mary left the cast to show her loyalty to BBC.

Do they waste food on Bake Off? ›

The judges may only eat a mouthful of each bake, but none of the tasty treats go to waste as the crew quickly steps up to the plate after filming. According to Noel Fielding in the 2018 Big Fat Quiz of the Year, the leftovers of the leftovers keep Prue's pigs well-fed.

Which Bake Off contestant did Paul Hollywood sleep with? ›

The former couple wed in 1998 and went on to have a son. The couple's marriage would begin to fall apart in 2013 and in July of that year Paul confessed to having an affair with chef Marcela Valladolid when he appeared on Bake Off's American spin-off.

Do Bake Off contestants get paid? ›

Do the contestants on The Great British Bake Off get paid? The answer to that is simply no - in fact, some are even left out of pocket for being on the show. Contestants have to pay for their own ingredients to practise at home, which can work out quite expensive.

Where do the bakers stay during Bake Off? ›

Do They Stay at the House Where the Tent Is Located? No. The contestants stay at a nearby hotel during the weekends and travel to the tent via minibus during competition days before returning home during the week, Quinn told Cosmopolitan. The judges and hosts are put up in a hotel, though a different one.

Who replaced Mel and Sue on Bake Off? ›

While double act Mel and Sue will be replaced by Sandi Toksvig (🙌) and, er, The Mighty Boosh's Noel Fielding. Leith, who is known for founding her London cookery school, has long been rumoured as Paul Hollywood's new partner in the kitchen.

Why did Noel leave baking show? ›

The comedian shocked fans earlier this month by announcing he was quitting the show after three series. He explained that it had become too much of a struggle juggling his various TV commitments. “Farewell Bake Off!” he wrote in a statement.

When did Mary Berry leave Bake Off? ›

Giedroyc and Perkins subsequently announced that they would not be returning when the show moved to its new network. On 22 September 2016, Berry announced that she would also be leaving the show when it moved to Channel 4, while Hollywood later announced he would stay.

Why did host leave Bake Off? ›

Put simply, Lucas was just not a good fit for the homey, welcoming vibe of Bake Off. (Note: the show is called the Great British Baking Show in the United States due to a trademark issue.) This tweet neatly sums up the backlash: “I absolutely hate Matt Lucas,” wrote one user.

Why did Freya leave Bake Off? ›

Sadly, It wasn't quite fancy enough as Paul and Prue referred to her cake as 'doughy' and 'under-baked', with too much dough compared to topping. Fans came to Freya's defence with one saying: "Nahhh did they really just send Freya home for having too little topping on her cake when George legit served up raw dough."

Who washes the dishes on Bake Off? ›

So, who does wash them? According to Faenia, it was ― at least at the time of the BBC interview ― one woman named Iva Vcelak (though the runners helped to bring dishes to her two-sink system). “Lovely Iva does all the washing-up.

Do they wash the clothes on Bake Off? ›

For continuity purposes, bakers are required to be in the same clothes all weekend. While this is generally fine if you are a tidy baker, it can be a nightmare on the second day for those who are messy. If they get covered in chocolate or icing they are forced to wash and dry their clothes overnight.

Do Bake Off contestants clean up? ›

GBBO contestants don't do the washing up themselves

There's no dishwasher on Bake Off, because the noise would disrupt filming. Instead, home economists spend 160 hours washing up everything by hand.

What was the controversy of Bake Off? ›

During season 4 judge Paul Hollywood was accused of favoring 21-year-old contestant Ruby Tandoh and giving her special treatment due to her looks, with many even going so far as to suggest the two were having an affair. Hollywood could have perhaps shot down the claims in a more professional and tactful manner.

Who is the most famous Bake Off winner? ›

Nadiya Hussain
Nadiya Hussain MBE
TelevisionThe Great British Bake Off The Chronicles of Nadiya Junior Bake Off Nadiya's British Food Adventure The Big Family Cooking Showdown Nadiya's Family Favourites Nadiya Bakes Nadiya's Time To Eat
SpouseAbdal Hussain ​ ( m. 2005)​
Children3
Websitewww.nadiyahussain.com
5 more rows

Who has made the most money from Bake Off? ›

Nadiya Hussain MBE, 38, won The Great British Bake Off in 2015, and earns the most of all the Bake Off winners.

Have any GBBO contestants dated? ›

Because reports that Great British Bake Off contestants Henry Bird and Alice Fevronia are dating have made our hearts totally swell with joy. Notably from Michael Chakraverty, who said “Such a beautiful couple" and Dan Chambers, with his “You guys!!!” and three heart emojis.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Frankie Dare

Last Updated:

Views: 6362

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (53 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Frankie Dare

Birthday: 2000-01-27

Address: Suite 313 45115 Caridad Freeway, Port Barabaraville, MS 66713

Phone: +3769542039359

Job: Sales Manager

Hobby: Baton twirling, Stand-up comedy, Leather crafting, Rugby, tabletop games, Jigsaw puzzles, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Frankie Dare, I am a funny, beautiful, proud, fair, pleasant, cheerful, enthusiastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.