The Dumpling Debate: Fried vs Steamed | The Dumpling School (2024)

The Dumpling Debate: Fried vs Steamed | The Dumpling School (1)

Did you know there is more than one way to prepare a dumpling! You can steam them for a soft chewy exterior or pan-fry them for a crispy crunchy bottom! Either way, you can’t go wrong with a dumpling, but there is a divide within the foodie community about which is better! This leads us to….The great dumpling debate! We are going to be talking a little bit more about each method of cooking, but we won’t be picking sides in this debate. We love all dumplings here at the Dumpling School There is no dumpling discrimination happening on our watch!

Steamed Dumplings

Like every dumpling, it starts with the basics: flour and water mixed together to form a smooth dough that is then rolled out and filled with a delectable filling, and finally is shaped. The most traditional filling is pork, however, you can really create a filling with a wide variety of ingredients such as beef, chicken, tofu, vegetables, etc. Once the dumplings are formed and crimped shut they can be placed in a steamer basket for roughly 10 to 15 minutes. The steaming process is what creates the shiny-looking soft exterior! Steaming is the traditional way of preparing dumplings and has never gone out of style. Many people around the world are loyal to this method of cooking and prefer it over pan-fried dumplings. Not only because of their soft texture but additionally because they are not greasy which can be easier to digest for some people.

Pan-Fried Dumplings

Pan-fried dumplings start off with the same base ingredients as steamed dumplings. A water flour dough is made, rolled out, and filled. Once filled the dumplings are crimped and ready to be cooked. To pan-fry dumplings you must first heat up a skillet and add oil to it. After a few moments of heating up the oil, you may place your dumplings into the pan. Be mindful of the flame! You don’t want to burn the bottoms of your dumplings. After a few minutes of cooking add water to the skillet and cover your dumplings for about 10 minutes. This creates a crispy bottom but a soft top. Giving you the best of both worlds with each bite. This method of cooking dumplings is enjoyed by people who can appreciate the added texture.

Attend a Dumpling Party at the Dumpling school!

Settle the dumpling debate by attending a dumpling party at The Dumpling School. Our expert chefs can show you how to prepare both steamed and pan-fried dumplings and we will let you be the judge of which is better! Who knows you might be like us and decide you like them both equally. Find out at our next Dumpling Party, book a party with us today!

The Dumpling Debate: Fried vs Steamed | The Dumpling School (2024)

FAQs

Are dumplings better fried or steamed? ›

The steaming process is what creates the shiny-looking soft exterior! Steaming is the traditional way of preparing dumplings and has never gone out of style. Many people around the world are loyal to this method of cooking and prefer it over pan-fried dumplings.

How unhealthy are fried dumplings? ›

Steamed dumplings are the best option in terms of fat content, with pan fried the next best. “If they do fry it -- like gyoza which are usually lightly fried -- then it puts the fat content up a little,” Austin said. “You want to avoid ones that have been completely deep fried.”

What is the difference between boiled and steamed dumplings? ›

Steaming Leaves Dumplings Plump And Firm

This cooking method yields dumplings with a wrapper that still feels silky but is firmer and more stretchy than those of boiled dumplings. A dumpling looks more plumped up, too, when it has been steamed.

Why are my dumplings still white? ›

The white phenomenon of cooked frozen dumplings' skin may be due to the low moisture content, and not entirely gelatinized starch after cooking.

Why is steamed better than fried? ›

Steaming is also better than frying at retaining nutrients in foods like vitamins, minerals and phytonutrients. When vegetables are stir-fried or deep fried, some heat-sensitive nutrients may be lost to the cooking oil or destroyed by the high temperatures.

Which is better steamed or fried? ›

Steaming also enhances the natural tastes of the food without overwhelming them. Furthermore, steaming is a comparatively rapid and effortless cooking method, devoid of intricate procedures. In contrast, when foods are fried or deep-fried, they are immersed in oil or fat, which may contribute to increased body weight.

Are steamed dumplings bad? ›

Steamed or boiled dumplings are healthy options, but do not forget about your fillings and serving sizes as well. One of the more popular options when it comes to dumplings are meat filled ones.

Are potstickers unhealthy? ›

Are Potstickers Unhealthy? Not inherently. It's true that potstickers are pan-fried on one side in oil, but other than that, they're a well-balanced mixture of carbs, protein, and fat. If you're trying to eat healthier, stick to vegetarian or vegan potstickers, or go with minced shrimp or chicken instead of pork.

What are the healthiest dumplings? ›

Dumplings with meat and fish contain more protein than pure vegetable fillings. The dumplings we found contained between 4.7g and 11g protein per 100g. We recommend choosing meat or fish dumplings that contain 6g or more protein per 100g.

Why are steamed dumplings so good? ›

Steaming will produce silky, tender dumplings with skin that is slightly firmer than that of boiled dumplings, but still stretchy. If you are making your own dumpling wrappers, use the hot water dough for this method, as this will give you a softer morsel.

What are steamed dumplings called? ›

Jiaozi. One of the most ubiquitous types of Chinese dumplings, jiaozi (饺子) are usually steamed or boiled and have been enjoyed across China for millennia. They often have a mixture of minced pork, shrimp, vegetables, mushrooms, and aromatics, along with a paper-thin dumpling wrapper.

Why are dumplings black? ›

Kluski czarne or (black dumplings), also known as kluski polskie (Polish dumplings) or kluski żelazne (iron dumplings), are a variety of dumplings popular in Silesia. In addition to minced potatoes and flour, the dough contains also potato starch, which adds to its colour.

Can pork dumplings be pink? ›

Yes. It's totally cooked,” answered Dan. I always thought pink pork meant that it was undercooked and therefore likely to make you sick. But these meatballs were cooked to a safe temperature.

What is dumpling mold? ›

Surface Sampling – Collecting of bulk material, swabbing a suspect area, or lifting visible growth using specialized tape. Generally used to confirm visible mold like growth. Wall Cavity Sampling – Is used to draw air from within a wall (or ceiling) cavity to again, test for the presence of microscopic mold spores.

Are dumplings supposed to be fried? ›

There are three basic ways: steaming, boiling, and steam-frying. There is also deep-frying or serving with a crispy lacy “skirt.” While the cooking method depends heavily upon your mood and what you are craving, it also depends on the shape of your dumpling.

What are the benefits of eating steamed dumplings? ›

Steamed Dim Sum: Dishes like har gow (shrimp dumplings) and siu mai (pork dumplings) are not only rich in protein but also low in calories. Steaming ensures that the nutrients, especially from seafood and vegetables, are preserved, providing essential vitamins and minerals.

What is the calorie difference between steamed and fried dumplings? ›

Sure, steaming saves calories, but whether it's enough to matter depends on what's inside. A steamed pork dumpling is around 80 calories – just ten fewer than the pan-fried version. Those stuffed with vegetables, on the other hand, are about 35 calories a piece.

Do you fry dumplings before steaming? ›

Pan-frying with a little water allows for your dumplings to be steamed at the same time as achieving the irresistible crispy base. Cooked from frozen, your dumplings are ready in 8-10 minutes.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Golda Nolan II

Last Updated:

Views: 6174

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (58 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Golda Nolan II

Birthday: 1998-05-14

Address: Suite 369 9754 Roberts Pines, West Benitaburgh, NM 69180-7958

Phone: +522993866487

Job: Sales Executive

Hobby: Worldbuilding, Shopping, Quilting, Cooking, Homebrewing, Leather crafting, Pet

Introduction: My name is Golda Nolan II, I am a thoughtful, clever, cute, jolly, brave, powerful, splendid person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.